'At least it's not a ghetto anymore': Experiencing gentrification and 'false choice urbanism' in Rotterdam's Afrikaanderwijk

《'At least it's not a ghetto anymore': Experiencing gentrification and 'false choice urbanism' in Rotterdam's Afrikaanderwijk》

打印

关键字: Afrikaanderwijk; class; community; displacement; 'false choice urbanism'; gentrification; housing; neighbourhood; Rotterdam; NEW-YORK-CITY; DISPLACEMENT; NEIGHBORHOOD; AMSTERDAM; COMMUNITY; POLICY; ISSUE

作者单位: [Doucet, Brian] Univ Waterloo, Sch Planning, 200 Univ Ave West, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada. Doucet, B (reprint author), Univ Waterloo, Sch Planning, 200 Univ Ave West, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada. E-Mail: brian.doucet@uwaterloo.ca

摘要: Gentrification has become a central pillar of urban policy in cities around the world. Proponents often frame it as a necessity and the sole alternative to neighbourhood decline. Critics call this a 'false choice' as it ignores other possibilities for improvement without gentrification. But how do working-class residents who live through the process of gentrification view the impact it has on their neighbourhood? Do they see it in such a stark binary way? This article addresses these questions by using qualitative interviews with long-term residents of the Afrikaanderwijk, a multicultural neighbourhood in Rotterdam where municipally-led gentrification is taking place. In contrast to much of the Anglo-Saxon literature on experiencing gentrification, our respondents had far more mixed, complex and ambivalent perspectives on the process. To some extent, this was due to the neighbourhood's recent history as a stigmatised 'ghetto' and the expectation that the arrival of white, ethnically Dutch middle-class people would help to improve the neighbourhood, which was ranked worst in the country in 2000. We also stress the role of local context, such as the early phase of gentrification and the comparatively strong social housing sector and tenant protection laws in the Netherlands, in contributing towards a more nuanced experience of gentrification.